Most Dallas business owners I talk to know what they spend on marketing each month. Far fewer know what it brings back. My digital marketing audit services cover that gap: a second opinion on whether your marketing, run by an agency or by your own team, produces revenue at a cost you can live with.
I’ve spent 20 years in digital marketing and content production, and I do every audit myself. I call the businesses I work with friends, so you get what I’d tell a friend, including “your agency is fine, keep them.”
What a digital marketing audit should answer
A good audit answers a few blunt questions:
- Can I trust the numbers in my reports?
- Which channels bring paying customers, and which just bring clicks?
- What does a new customer cost me right now?
- Am I getting what my contract says I pay for?
My take: if nobody can tell you what a new customer costs, your marketing runs on autopilot, and autopilot is expensive. The metrics I judge it by are in my guide to running a marketing performance audit.
What I check
My background is journalism, so I read agency reports the way a reporter reads a press release: looking for what’s left out.
I test Google Analytics and Search Console by hand: is each call or form fill counted once, twice, or never? Bad tracking makes every number a guess.
I go through your site like a customer would, phone first. Every broken form or buried phone number on that path is a leak.
What each channel costs against what it brings in, and whether its leads ever turn into paying customers.
Whether anything you publish moves people toward a sale. Posting volume on its own proves nothing.
Whether your list gets mailed at all and what happens after someone buys once. Often the cheapest money left on the table.
Who owns your ad accounts and domain, what the contract promises versus what the report shows, and how hard leaving would be.
For the website itself, here’s my honest answer to what counts as a good conversion rate for a website.
What audits usually turn up
The expensive problems are rarely clever. They’re basics nobody has checked in a while.
Take Rival Sign Company, a veteran-owned, family-run sign and wrap shop in the Fort Worth area that came to me for a new website. The old site listed the wrong business hours and an outdated email. The contact form didn’t work. Their 3M Preferred Installer certification, a real reason to pick them, wasn’t mentioned anywhere.
None of that shows up in a traffic report. All of it turns away people who were ready to call. Here’s how each gap got closed in the Rival Sign Company case study.
A hand-coded site, a quote form that takes iPhone photos, new hosting and fixed DNS. Budget: $2,500. Read the full case.
Elsewhere, the usual suspects: forms emailing an inbox nobody checks, ad accounts registered to the agency, reports full of impressions with no revenue line.
What you get at the end
A written report in plain English, without a padded slide deck. Every finding says what’s wrong, why it costs you money, and how hard it is to fix.
- Findings for each area I checked, with screenshots where they help
- A fix list ranked by impact against effort, so the cheap wins sit on top
- A call where I walk you through it
Anyone competent can act on that list: your agency, your in-house team, a freelancer, or me.
After the audit: fix it yourself, keep your agency, or bring me in
Some fixes take an afternoon and you’ll handle them yourself. If your agency is solid, keep them and hand them the list. If the findings point the other way, read up on the red flags that show an agency is wasting your budget and how to tell when it’s time to fire your marketing agency.
An audit that always ends with “hire me” is a sales pitch with a spreadsheet attached. If your agency is doing good work, I’ll say so in writing.
If you want me on the fixes, I take the parts I’m strongest at, like rebuilding a website that loses leads or email marketing that brings past customers back. Scope and price are set after a short call, with no obligation past the audit.
Who this isn’t for: if you haven’t started marketing, there’s nothing to audit yet. And if you want a document that justifies firing your agency no matter what it finds, I’m the wrong person.
FAQ: Digital Marketing Audit in Dallas
How much do digital marketing audit services cost?
It depends on how many channels you run and how tangled the access is. A Dallas shop with a website and a couple of social accounts is a lighter job than a company running ads and email through an agency. I set scope and price after a short call.
How long does a marketing audit take?
Mostly it depends on access. Once I’m into your analytics, ad accounts, website and email platform, the work moves fast. For Dallas businesses I give a delivery date on the first call. If an agency stalls on access, that goes into the report as a finding.
What do you need from me to start?
Read access to Google Analytics, Search Console, your ad accounts, website admin and email platform, plus recent agency reports and the contract. Plenty of Dallas owners don’t know where those logins live, which is normal. Finding out who controls what is part of the audit.
Do I need to tell my agency I’m getting an audit?
You don’t have to, but I’d recommend it, since access often comes through them anyway. A good Dallas agency won’t mind a second opinion, and I’d expect the friends I work with to bring one in on mine. An agency that fights you over read access is telling you something.
Is an audit worth it if my marketing seems to be working?
Often, yes. “Seems to be working” usually means leads arrive, but nobody has checked what each one costs or which channel produced it. Sometimes one channel carries the load while the rest just spend. Sometimes the audit confirms your Dallas agency is doing well, which is worth knowing before you renew.